Published by Tekmetric
Subscribe
The Repair Order

/

Shop Finance & Growth

Shop Finance & Growth

Auto Repair Shop P&L Benchmarks: Where Your Money Should Be Going

Words

Benjamin Johnson

Auto Repair Shop P&L Benchmarks: Where Your Money Should Be Going

Picture a shop that brings in $1 million a year. After paying for the parts and the technicians who install them, about half of that is left. After rent, the service advisor, insurance, utilities, supplies, advertising, software, and the owner's own paycheck, the owner keeps about $100,000, which is a dime out of every dollar.

Is a dime good? It depends on what you compare it to. This guide lays out the public benchmarks that exist for auto repair shop profit and loss statements, shows you how to read your own P&L against them, and is honest about where the data runs thin.

How should a repair shop P&L be organized?

Most shop P&L statements fail before the first number is entered. They lump technician pay into payroll, mix parts cost with shop supplies, and bury the owner's salary in officer compensation. You can't benchmark a statement built that way.

Two profitability measures matter most to shop owners. Gross profit is what's left after you pay for the parts and the technician who installed them. Net profit is what's left after you keep the lights on.

A good shop P&L statement has a few layers:

  • Sales. Split into labor sales, parts sales, and anything else you sell in volume (tires, fees, etc.). Each line gets its own row.
  • Cost of sales. Parts cost sits under parts sales. Technician wages, including flat-rate pay, bonuses, and payroll taxes on those wages, sit under labor sales.
  • Gross profit. Total sales minus cost of sales. Calculate it for labor, for parts, and for the whole shop.
  • Operating expenses. Everything else: rent, mortgage, service advisor and office wages, owner salary, insurance, utilities, shop supplies, advertising, software, equipment, interest, and depreciation.
  • Net profit. This is gross profit minus operating expenses.

What gross profit margin should a repair shop run?

Go back to the shop above. It keeps $530,000 of its $1 million, a 53% gross profit. Now say it tightens up its parts pricing and lifts parts gross profit by six points. That's $27,000 more a year with the same cars and the same technicians.

More than half of shops clear 50% gross profit. That's the headline from the 2024 Ratchet+Wrench Industry Survey, a trade-magazine survey of repair shop owners. Here's how the shops broke out:

  • 60% or higher: about one in five shops
  • 50% to 59%: about one in three shops
  • Under 40%: about one in five shops
  • Don't track it: one in 10 shops

Accountants and business coaches who specialize in repair shops typically coach toward 50% to 55% gross profit on parts and 60% to 70% on labor. Those are targets, not averages. They tell you where well-run shops aim, not where the median shop sits.

Here is how to find yours:

  • Parts gross profit is parts sales minus parts cost, divided by parts sales.
  • Labor gross profit is labor sales minus technician wages and payroll taxes, divided by labor sales.
  • Overall gross profit is total sales minus all cost of sales, divided by total sales.

Be sure to run all three calculations to get a clear view of your business. A healthy overall number can hide a parts margin that is bleeding.

What should technician pay and labor rates look like?

Say your posted labor rate is $140 and your technician makes $30 an hour. On a day the technician bills all eight hours, you bring in $1,120 in labor sales and keep $880 of it after wages. That's a 79% labor gross profit.

Now say the same technician bills only five hours. You still pay for eight. Labor sales drop to $700 and you keep $460, a 66% labor gross profit for the same technician, same rate, and same paycheck. The only thing that changed was the hours billed, and it cost you 13 points of margin.

That is why labor gross profit lives or dies on two numbers: what you charge and how many hours you actually bill.

On wages, the national median for automotive service technicians was $50,620 a year in May 2025, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the federal agency that tracks employer-reported pay. The mean hourly wage was $24.34. The top 10% of technicians earned $81,790 or more, and the bottom 10% earned $34,660 or less. The spread matters. A shop in a high-wage metro paying $38 an hour needs a very different labor rate than one paying $22.

One in four shops now posts a labor rate of $150 or more. That's the top finding on rates from the 2026 Ratchet+Wrench Industry Survey. Here's where the rest landed:

  • $150 or higher: one in four shops
  • $120 to $129: about one in six shops
  • Under $80: fewer than one in 10 shops

The benchmark that connects these two numbers is effective labor rate: total labor sales divided by total hours technicians were paid. In the five-hour example above, you billed $700 but paid for eight hours. Your effective labor rate that day was $87.50, not $140. The gap is wages you paid for hours you never billed. Be sure to track it weekly.

What do operating expenses look like as a share of sales?

This is where the public data gets thin, and you should know that before you trust any number you read.

The only broad, verifiable breakdown of shop expenses comes from federal tax returns. ProjectionHub, a financial-forecasting firm, analyzed more than 228,000 sole-proprietor auto repair returns from 2019. Here's where the money went, as a share of sales:

  • Parts: about a third
  • Supplies: 7%
  • Rent: 6%
  • Vehicle expenses: 5%
  • Depreciation: 4%
  • Utilities: 3%
  • Taxes: 2%
  • Net profit: 10%

Take these numbers as directional rather than a concrete path. They come from sole proprietors with average sales of about $68,000, so the sample is mostly one- and two-person operations. And because an owner's own labor isn't an expense on a sole-proprietor return, technician wages show up far lower than they would at a shop with a payroll.

Still, the data shows where overhead goes. Rent, supplies, and utilities together eat 15 to 16 cents of every dollar at the small end of the industry.

Rent is the one to watch, because it doesn't change when sales do. A shop paying $5,000 a month in rent spends 6% of sales on it at $1 million a year. If that same shop grows to $1.5 million, the rent stays $5,000 but drops to 4% of sales. If sales slip to $750,000, the same rent climbs to 8%. That's why bigger shops usually run a lower rent percentage, and why a slow year hurts twice.

For everything else, the honest answer is that there is no current, public, verifiable benchmark for insurance, advertising, software, or office wages as a share of sales at a full-size repair shop. Use the previous 12-month period as the baseline and watch for drift quarter to quarter.

What net profit should a repair shop expect?

Back to the $1 million shop keeping a dime on the dollar, or $100,000. It lands right in the middle of the pack.

Shops land all over the map on net profit, according to the 2024 Ratchet+Wrench Industry Survey. Here's how they broke out:

  • 20% or higher: about one in five shops
  • 15% to 19%: about one in five shops
  • 10% to 14%: one in five shops
  • Under 10%: about one in eight shops
  • No net profit at all: one in 25 shops
  • Don't track it: about one in five shops

Add up the top three bands and roughly six in 10 shops are at 10% or better. Notice the other finding hiding in that list: one in five owners can't tell you what they keep.

The number that should stop you is this one: 22% of shops said they don't track net profit margin. More than one in five owners could not tell you what their profit margins are.

Coaches commonly set 20% net profit as the target for a well-run shop. At $1 million in sales, the gap between 10% and 20% is $100,000 a year, and most of it comes from gross profit.

What are the shops that track their numbers doing differently?

Tracking your numbers is the one habit the survey ties directly to higher revenue. In the 2026 Ratchet+Wrench survey, 86% of respondents said they track key performance indicators, and shops that do were three times more likely to exceed $1 million in annual revenue. The KPIs the report lists are the same lines on your P&L: share of sales from maintenance, repair, and tires, overall gross profit, parts gross profit, labor gross profit, and net profit.

The average repair order tells the same story. Almost three-quarters of surveyed shops, 74%, reported an average repair order of $800 or more, and 15% reported $2,000 or more. Another 15% said they don't measure it.

One thing to note: geography is important. A $150 labor rate in Houston and a $150 labor rate in rural Nebraska are not the same business. Benchmark against shops your size in markets like yours wherever you can, and treat national figures as a sanity check, not a target.

You can't benchmark a number you don't track. That is the first fix, and it costs nothing.

How to benchmark your shop this week

  1. Pull your previous 12-month P&L data and add a percent-of-sales column.
  2. Move technician wages and payroll taxes out of payroll and under labor sales. Move parts cost under parts sales.
  3. Calculate parts gross profit, labor gross profit, and overall gross profit. Compare that to 50%, the mark more than half of shops clear.
  4. Calculate effective labor rate: labor sales divided by paid technician hours. Compare that to your posted rate.
  5. Calculate net profit. See where you land against the net profit numbers above.
  6. Pick the single line furthest from the coaching benchmarks. Fix that one first.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good gross profit margin for an auto repair shop?

More than half of surveyed shops run 50% or higher overall, according to the 2024 Ratchet+Wrench Industry Survey. Coaches who work with shops typically target 50% to 55% on parts and 60% to 70% on labor.

What is a good net profit margin for an auto repair shop?

Roughly six in 10 shops that track it report 10% or better, and about one in five report 20% or more. Twenty percent net is the figure coaches commonly treat as the mark of a well-run shop.

What percentage of revenue should rent be for a repair shop?

IRS data on sole-proprietor repair shops shows rent at about 6% of revenue, but that sample skews very small. Larger shops typically run lower because rent doesn't scale with sales.

What is the average labor rate for an auto repair shop?

In the 2026 Ratchet+Wrench Industry Survey, 25% of shops posted $150 or more per hour, and 17% posted $120 to $129. Rates vary widely by market.

How much do technicians make?

The national median wage for automotive service technicians was $50,620 in May 2025, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

‍

Sources

FILED UNDER

Shop Finance & Growth

THE PEOPLE BEHIND THE STORY

Benjamin Johnson

The Repair Order covers the work, the business and the people of independent auto repair. Published by Tekmetric.

Keep reading

All stories →