Published by Tekmetric
Subscribe
The Repair Order

/

Shop Finance & Growth

Shop Finance & Growth

Before You Open a Second Location, Make Sure the First One Runs Without You

Words

Benjamin Johnson

Before You Open a Second Location, Make Sure the First One Runs Without You

Editor's note: This piece was written by Ed Pate, who spent 25 years owning and operating his own auto repair shop, consulting for shop owners, and helping multi-shop organizations scale. He is now a customer training manager at Tekmetric, where he trains shop owners and their teams on operations.

The most common mistake I saw operators make when scaling to multiple shops had nothing to do with the new location. It had everything to do with the one they already had.

‍

In 25 years running my own shop, consulting for others, and scaling multi-shop organizations, I watched good operators sign leases on location two before they ever answered the most important question: Can my current shop run for five full business days without a single decision from me?

‍

Not mostly. Not if nothing goes wrong. Five clean days of operation.

‍

If the answer is no, you're not ready to scale. You're simply cloning your stress to a second location.

What I Watched Happen

I've worked alongside multi-shop operators at every stage. The ones who scaled successfully shared one thing in common: their original shop ran on documented systems, not on their personal presence.

‍

The ones who struggled had built a shop that ran on them: their approvals, their relationships, their judgment calls. The moment they split their attention, the original location drifted. Car count softened. Average repair order (ARO) dropped. The phone rang constantly because no one on the floor had the authority or the process to handle what came up.

‍

I saw one operator's first location drop 11% in car count within three months of opening his second shop. That's not a staffing problem. That's a systems problem.

The Foundation Has to Come First

A shop that runs on your personality doesn't scale. A shop that runs on documented processes does.

‍

Before any operator I work with is ready to grow, I ask to see four process categories in place. This means they are not in the owner's head, but written down, trained to, and tested.

‍

Operational processes. Every step a vehicle goes through from write-up to delivery is documented. A process that lives in someone's head walks out the door every time that person does. Without it, every employee invents their own version of how to do things and you lose consistency on both ARO and customer experience.

‍

Training processes. Operators with formal 30-60-90-day new hire training programs got new service advisors to full productivity faster than those who trained informally. One shop I consulted with had no defined ramp. Advisors were taking unsupervised calls on day three and developing habits that took months to correct. After building a structured training process, new hires reached a consistent service approval rate by day 60 that previously took five to six months.

‍

Career processes. People leave when they can't see where they're going. The shops that retained their best people had written career ladders such as lube tech to B tech to A tech and service advisor to service manager. Replacing a trained technician conservatively costs $8,000 to $12,000 in recruiting, downtime, and ramp time, plus thousands more in lost production revenue. A visible career path is one of the cheapest retention tools available.

‍

Financial processes. Every shop preparing to expand needs a financial dashboard that someone other than the owner can read and act upon every day. When the owner is the only person who understands the numbers, those numbers stop getting managed the moment the owner's attention shifts to a new location. I've seen parts-pricing errors run uncorrected for months because no one else had been given ownership of the morning financial review. Know your effective labor rate, your parts gross profit percentage, and your car count trend at every location, every single day. If you don't have someone in each shop who owns those numbers, that's the first hire you need to make before you think about expanding.

Technology Is a Force Multiplier, but Only If the Foundation Is There

Processes get you to the starting line. The right technology gets you across it faster.

‍

The operators I watched run multiple locations efficiently did a few things consistently. They checked repair order status, technician productivity, parts gross profit, and daily revenue for every shop from one screen, every morning, without calling anyone. Instead of reacting to problems after they've cost money, owners can catch the drift early. That kind of oversight is simply not possible when you're managing by walking the floor of one building at a time.

‍

Digital vehicle inspections are where I've seen the most direct impact. When a technician documents findings with photos and the service advisor sends them to the customer's phone, the conversation changes entirely. You're no longer asking someone to take your word for it. You're showing them. Approval times come down, ARO goes up, and the trust that builds generates referrals and return visits.

‍

I worked with a multi-shop organization that transitioned from a legacy management system to a modern platform. In their first full year, they saw an average 28.9% increase in revenue across all locations. That number didn't come from the software alone. The processes were already in place. The technology amplified what was already working.

‍

Here's the key distinction: technology scales what you already do well. It also scales what you do poorly. Get the process right first, then let the technology run it at scale.

Build the Machine Before You Buy the Building

The operators who expanded without this foundation didn't just struggle with the new location. They damaged the one that was already working. They lost gross profit at the original shop and decisions were made without authority or process. These costs don't show up on a single line of the profit and loss statement, but they add up fast.

‍

If you're planning to grow, start the process work before you sign the next lease or purchase a second building. Spend 90 days documenting every repeatable task in your current shop. If a process lives only in your head or your best employee's head, it is a liability. Get it on paper, train to it, and stress-test it: take a full week away and see what breaks.

‍

Get that right with one location and the technology you use to scale becomes an investment instead of an expense. Skip it, and every new location inherits the same fragility as the first.

‍

Sources

FILED UNDER

Shop Finance & Growth

THE PEOPLE BEHIND THE STORY

Benjamin Johnson

The Repair Order covers the work, the business and the people of independent auto repair. Published by Tekmetric.

Keep reading

All stories →