Shop Operations

Picture your shop running $150,000 a month. You know every car on the lot. When a repair order stalls, you notice before anyone tells you. When a technician is having a bad week, you can see it from the counter.
Now picture the same $150,000 shop, plus a second one 20 minutes away doing $70,000 and climbing slowly. You are in the truck four days a week. Both shops are running at about 80% of what they should be because you are giving each one half of the attention that made the first one work.
That is the transition multi-shop owners must navigate. It is not a scale problem. It is a job change. Your income used to come from cars you touched, and now it comes from decisions other people make in a building you are not standing in.
Your first shop runs on process. Most of it just isn't written anywhere.
You know that a car with a check engine light gets a diagnostic sold before anything else gets quoted. You know which parts vendor to call second when the first one is out. You know that the customer who asks three questions about brake pads is going to ask three more, so you build 15 extra minutes into that phone call. Nobody trained you on any of that. You built it, and then you became the place it lives.
At one location, being the process works fine. At two, it stops working immediately, because you can only be in one building at a time. Whatever isn't written down gets reinvented at the second shop by whoever happens to be standing there. Sometimes they reinvent it well. Often they don't, and you find out six weeks later when a customer calls you directly about something your second location handled in a way your first location never would.
Here is the uncomfortable math of location two. You are no longer selling work, fixing cars, or handling upset customers. You are selecting and coaching the person who does.
Gallup, the workplace research firm that has surveyed millions of employees across two decades, found in its research on managers that managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement between business units. Read that plainly: when one team is running hot and another team in the same company is dragging, most of the difference traces back to the person leading it, not to the pay plan, the building, or the market.
Gallup also estimates that about one in 10 people has strong natural talent for managing others, with another two in 10 having enough to work with if they get real coaching. That is roughly three in 10 people who can do this job well, which means the odds are against the lead technician you were planning to promote on Monday.
That is not a reason to avoid promoting from within. Your best technician often does become your best manager. It is a reason to stop assuming the promotion is the plan and start treating manager selection as the highest-stakes decision in the whole expansion. You can fix a bad parts vendor in a week. A bad manager at your second location costs you a year and a customer base.
Most owners budget the lease, the lift, and the sign. Fewer budget the org chart.
Say you promote your lead technician to run location one so you can be at location two. You just made two decisions at once. You added a supervisor's salary, and you took a producer out of the bay.
Federal wage data puts a number on the first part. The Bureau of Labor Statistics tracks automotive service technicians and mechanics under occupation code 49-3023, and first-line supervisors of mechanics, installers, and repairers under code 49-1011. In the May 2023 national wage estimates, the median annual wage was $47,770 for technicians and $75,820 for those supervisors. Same reference period, same survey, so the comparison is fair. The gap is about $28,000 a year.
Then run that against what a shop actually keeps. Paar, Melis & Associates, an accounting firm that specializes in repair shops, reported an average net profit of 9.6% in its 2025 benchmark report built from its own clients' financials. That sample is self-selected, since it reflects shops already working with a specialist CPA, so read it as a good-shop number rather than an industry average.
At a 9.6% net margin, covering $28,000 of new salary out of new profit takes roughly $292,000 in additional annual revenue. That is about $24,000 a month in work you were not doing before, just to pay for the person who lets you leave the building.
Now the second half. Your lead technician was billing hours. At a $140 labor rate and 35 billed hours a week, those hands were producing about $4,900 a week, or roughly $255,000 a year in labor sales. Those are round hypothetical figures, not a benchmark, so put your own labor rate and your own tech's billed hours in their place. Whatever number you get, it leaves the bay the day the promotion starts, unless you backfill first.
Add both halves together before you sign the lease. The management layer is usually the largest single cost of a second location, and it almost never shows up in the pro forma.
Owners tend to file standardized processes under administration. Customers experience it as trust.
Think about one customer, one repair. They call and get quoted a diagnostic fee. They drop off and get told when to expect a call. They get the call. They approve some work and decline some. They get told the car is ready at a certain time. They pay and leave. That is six separate moments where your shop either does what it said it would do or doesn't.
McKinsey, the management consulting firm, has illustrated what that stack does to satisfaction. If you get each of six interactions right 95% of the time, roughly one in four customers still walks away from the overall experience unhappy, because the misses compound. Ninety-five percent per touchpoint feels excellent. Across the whole visit it isn't.
Now open a second location where those six moments are handled slightly differently, and you have two shops with the same sign producing two different experiences. Customers do not grade you against your other location. They grade you against what they were told last time.
The satisfaction research points at the same pressure point. J.D. Power's 2024 U.S. Aftermarket Service Index study surveyed 10,264 vehicle owners between January and March of that year. Satisfaction in the full-service maintenance and repair segment climbed 12 points on the study's 1,000-point scale, and the firm attributed the improvement largely to service adviser performance and courtesy. The counter is where satisfaction is won. The counter is also the role you stop supervising the day you split your time.
So the process you write down should follow the customer, not the paperwork. Who calls, when, and says what. What gets photographed and sent. What a declined repair triggers, and when somebody follows up on it. Digital vehicle inspection makes a lot of this easier to keep consistent, because a photo and a note travel between locations in a way that a verbal handoff never does, but the standard has to exist before the tool can enforce it.
There is a version of the second-location plan where scale solves hiring. Two shops, bigger name, better candidates. It rarely plays out that way, because you are now competing for technicians in a market that is short on them and you have twice as many seats to fill.
The TechForce Foundation, a nonprofit that tracks technician supply and demand using federal completions and employment data, projected in its 2024 report that the transportation industry would need an estimated 971,000 new technicians between 2024 and 2028 across automotive, diesel, collision, and aviation. Be precise about what that figure is. It is projected demand across four sectors over five years, and it is driven mostly by replacement as people retire and leave rather than by growth. TechForce found replacement needs outpacing growth by more than four to one in the automotive, diesel, and collision segments. It is not a count of open jobs today. What it does establish is that the pipeline is structurally tight, and that your second location is hiring into that.
Retention matters more than recruiting here, and retention is a management problem. WrenchWay, an industry platform that surveys technicians alongside the National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence, reported in its 2025 Voice of the Technician survey of roughly 5,000 respondents that about three in 10 technicians never sit down with their manager individually at all, while another three in 10 do it weekly. The same survey found 67% of technicians calling paid training a must-have, about two in three, while only 51% said their shop provides it, or about half. Those respondents opted into the survey themselves, so the sample skews toward technicians engaged enough to answer, and the percentages should be read as signal rather than census.
Still, the signal is worth taking seriously. Weekly touchbases and paid training are both things that quietly stop happening at the location the owner visits least.
Standardize the things where variation costs money or trust:
The customer communication sequence, from first call to pickup. Diagnostic and estimating procedure, including what has to be documented before anything gets quoted. Quality control before a car goes back to the customer, since a returned vehicle at your new location does more damage to your name than one at your established shop. Pay plans and how production is measured, because two different pay structures across two locations will eventually put your own technicians in competition with each other. Training expectations and certification targets.
On that last one, the National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence, known as ASE, gives you a ready-made standard instead of one you have to invent. Its Blue Seal recognition requires at least 75% of a shop's service staff to hold ASE certification. Whether or not you pursue the recognition, three out of four certified is a target both locations can be measured against.
Leave alone the things that are local and cost you nothing:
Shop hours that fit the neighborhood. The mix of work, since a location surrounded by fleet accounts should not be forced into the same job mix as one surrounded by commuters. Vendor relationships where a local supplier genuinely delivers faster. How the manager runs the morning meeting.
The distinction is straightforward. Standardize the promise. Localize the logistics. Owners who standardize everything build a system nobody at the second location believes in, and the process gets quietly abandoned the first busy week.
Compare the two shops on the same measures, same week, and look at the gap rather than the totals:
Gross profit percentage on labor and on parts, tracked separately for each location. Technician efficiency, meaning the number of billed hours divided by hours worked. Percentage of recommended work that gets approved. Returned vehicle rate. Average days from a declined repair to a follow-up contact.
The point of running them side by side is that a gap tells you something a total never will. If location two sells 38% of the work it finds and location one sells 55%, that is not a market difference, it is a process difference, and it is fixable. On a shop finding $1,200 of work a day, those 17 points are about $200 a day walking out the door, or roughly $4,000 a month.
One more measure, and it is about you. Count the days you spent at each location last month. If the answer is that both shops needed you, the process you needed to write down before opening still isn't written.
How long before a second location is profitable? There is no credible published figure specific to repair shops, so be skeptical of anyone who quotes one. For general context, federal Business Employment Dynamics data shows about half of all new business establishments surviving five years, with 51.4% of the establishments that opened in March 2020 still operating five years later. That covers all industries and all new establishments rather than second locations specifically, so use it as a reminder that new sites are fragile, not as a forecast for yours.
Should I promote a technician or hire an outside manager? Both work. The mistake is treating the promotion as automatic because someone is your best producer. Managing is a different job, and Gallup's research suggests a minority of people are naturally suited to it. If you promote internally, budget for real management training and expect to coach weekly for the first year.
What is the single most important thing to standardize before opening? Customer communication. It is the process customers actually experience, it is the one J.D. Power's research ties most directly to satisfaction, and it is the easiest to get wrong when a new service adviser is improvising under pressure.
Do I need the same software and systems at both locations? You need the same definitions. If technician efficiency, approval rate, and gross profit are calculated differently at each shop, you cannot compare the two, and comparison is the only way you will find out which location has a problem.
Can I run two shops without a full-time manager at one of them? Some owners do it for a while, usually by splitting weeks and leaning hard on a strong service adviser. It works until something breaks at both locations in the same week. Plan the management layer as a cost of opening, not as a reward for succeeding.
FILED UNDER
Shop Operations
THE PEOPLE BEHIND THE STORY