Shop Finance & Growth

Editor’s note: This piece was written by Bryan Stasch, vice president of coaching, peer groups, and member success at Auto Shop Answers, a Houston-based training and coaching company for repair shop owners. He started in the industry as a technician in 1984, co-owned three repair shops, and has spent more than 25 years coaching shop owners and their leadership teams.
There comes a point in the growth of an auto repair business when working harder stops working.
The business might be producing record revenue. The team is larger. There are more technicians, more customers, better systems, and perhaps multiple locations. From the outside, the company looks successful.
But inside, the owner may be experiencing something very different.
Managers still bring problems to the owner. Important decisions wait for the owner. Difficult customer situations find their way to the owner. Hiring decisions require the owner. Employees bypass managers because they know the owner will give them an answer. The business has grown, but the leadership structure hasn’t.
Eventually, every successful shop owner has to confront an important question: Can this business continue to grow if I remain one of the primary people required to make it work?
For many owners, the next stage isn’t about hiring another technician, adding another service adviser, or even finding another manager. It might be about developing another executive. In some cases, it might be time to start hiring for a chief operating officer.
One of the biggest mistakes owners make is confusing a strong manager with an executive.
A great service manager can effectively manage workflow, technicians, advisers, customers, and daily production. A general manager can oversee multiple departments and take tremendous responsibility off the owner’s plate.
Those are important roles. But the transition to COO requires something more.
The COO isn’t simply responsible for getting things done. The COO becomes responsible for building an organization capable of consistently getting the right things done without requiring the owner to drive everything forward.
That requires thinking beyond today’s repair orders, staffing problems, and production numbers.
A COO must learn to think about execution, systems, people, performance, capacity, accountability, and leadership. Most importantly, a COO must learn to develop other leaders rather than becoming the person everyone depends upon. Otherwise, we’ve simply replaced one problem with another and switched the owner bottleneck with a management one.
Think about how most repair businesses are built.
In the beginning, the owner does almost everything from answering the phone to working on cars. As the company grows, you add people and transfer responsibilities. But growth also creates complexity.
More technicians require more production management. More advisers require more sales leadership. More employees create more communication and accountability needs. More revenue creates greater financial complexity. Multiple locations multiply the need for leadership, systems, consistency, and decision-making.
Eventually, the owner’s personal capacity becomes one of the constraints on the organization. That doesn’t mean the owner has failed. It often means the business has outgrown the leadership structure that created its success.
The question changes from running the business itself to building a leadership structure, which is an entirely different strategy.
This might sound strange in an article about COO development, but I wouldn’t begin by putting COO on someone’s business card.
Start with the work. Take a hard look at your organization and ask: What still requires me that shouldn’t? Look at the decisions reaching you every week, your calendar, the problems people bring you, meetings that don’t function well without you, and what departments you still personally drive. Then ask: Who should eventually own these outcomes?
You might discover that someone already inside your organization has the potential to become that leader. We often evaluate people based on what they’re capable of doing today instead of considering what they could become capable of doing tomorrow. You aren’t simply looking for someone who can run the shop. You’re looking for someone who can develop the capacity to lead the operating organization.
I like to simplify the CEO/COO relationship this way: The CEO executes the vision, strategy, and growth. The COO is responsible for the execution, systems, people, and performance.
There will naturally be overlap. Financial performance, leadership development, culture, strategic execution, and organizational capacity require both executives. But the distinction matters.
The CEO should increasingly ask: Where are we going?
The COO should increasingly ask: What must the organization become capable of doing to get us there?
Imagine an owner wants to grow from one location to three. That's the vision. But vision doesn’t create scalability.
Someone must determine what three locations require in management structure, technician capacity, staffing, processes, key performance indicators, communication, accountability, training, systems, and leadership.
The CEO sees the opportunity. The COO builds the organizational capability required to execute it.
That’s when the relationship becomes more than delegation. It becomes an executive partnership.
Here’s where many owners struggle.
They identify a capable manager and begin handing things over. People problems. Production. Meetings. Hiring. Customer complaints. Scheduling. Pretty soon, that manager has an enormous list of responsibilities. But more responsibility doesn’t automatically create greater executive capability.
COOs have to be developed.
They need to learn how to make decisions without constantly seeking owner approval. They need enough financial acumen to understand how operational decisions affect gross profit, payroll, cash flow, and profitability.
They also need to understand organizational capacity and identify constraints. They need to build systems instead of repeatedly solving the same problems, conduct difficult accountability conversations, and coach while developing future leaders. And they need to anticipate what tomorrow’s business will require instead of merely responding to what today’s business demands. Perhaps most importantly, they need to develop executive judgment.
A developing manager asks: “What do you want me to do?” A developing executive says: “Here’s what I’m seeing. Here are the options. Here’s what I recommend.” Eventually, you want to hear: “I’ve got it. I’ll keep you informed.”
That’s not just a change in language. It’s evidence that leadership capacity is being transferred.
There is another side of COO development that doesn’t receive enough attention. Owners cannot develop a COO while continuing to behave as if they’re the only person allowed to lead. The owner has to develop, too.
You must learn to transfer authority along with responsibility. That means allowing another capable leader to make some decisions differently than you would. It also means resisting the temptation to jump back in whenever things become uncomfortable, and refusing to let employees bypass leadership because coming directly to you is faster.
It means replacing, “I’ll take care of it,” with, “Who should own this?”
This is why developing a COO isn’t only COO development. It’s CEO development, too. If the COO keeps sending decisions upward, the owner remains the bottleneck. If the CEO keeps taking decisions back, the COO never develops.
Both leaders have to evolve.
Here’s an exercise you can do today. Ask yourself: If I disappeared from the business for 30 days tomorrow, what would break?
Don’t think about whether you could leave. Imagine you had no choice.
Your answers reveal where the organization still depends on you. For every dependency you identify, ask two more questions: Who should eventually own this? And what prevents them from owning it today?
Maybe the problem is clarity. They don’t know what they own. Maybe it’s capability. They haven’t been developed yet. Maybe it is authority. You’ve given them responsibility but still require your approval. Maybe it’s a missing system. Maybe it’s accountability. Those questions begin turning owner dependency into a leadership-development strategy.
There’s one more question that’s equally important. Once you’ve identified the potential COO, ask: If that person disappeared for 30 days, what would break?
This is where COO development can go wrong. The objective isn’t to transfer every dependency from the owner to one highly capable manager. The COO must also build leaders beneath them. A mature COO doesn’t measure success by how many problems they can personally solve. They measure success by how capable the organization becomes because of their leadership.
Instead of answering every question, they begin asking: What do you recommend? Instead of owning every decision: Who should own this? Instead of repeatedly fixing problems: What keeps causing this?
That’s how leadership capacity begins multiplying throughout the organization.
Some owners resist the idea of greater independence because they equate being needed with being valuable. Those aren’t the same thing. The goal isn’t to make the owner unnecessary; it is to make the owner’s daily involvement unnecessary. There is an enormous difference.
As the organization develops, the owner’s highest value should increasingly come from vision, strategy, leadership development, growth, relationships, capital allocation, acquisitions, and building enterprise value, not from solving Tuesday afternoon’s production problem.
That’s why developing a COO is much bigger than filling a position. You’re building leadership capacity, creating organizational capacity, and reducing key-person dependency. You’re creating room for the CEO to actually become the CEO. And you’re beginning to create something many owners wanted when they started their businesses but unintentionally built themselves out of: choice.
The choice to work in the business because you want to, not because the business requires you to. That’s when you’ve moved beyond simply building a successful repair shop. You’re building an enterprise capable of performing beyond its owner.
And that’s where owner independence truly begins.
Bryan Stasch works with auto repair shop owners and their leadership teams to develop stronger executives, build leadership capacity, improve business performance, and create businesses that are less dependent on the owner. His work focuses on CEO and COO development, financial and operational performance, leadership systems, enterprise value, and owner independence.
FILED UNDER
Shop Finance & Growth
THE PEOPLE BEHIND THE STORY