.jpg)
Table of contents
Editor's note: This piece was written by Tess Fetter, who co-owns Fetter Automotive Repair in Mesa, Arizona with her husband, Marty, a technician and former shop foreman. They opened the shop in 2023.
Most of my customer service happens before a vehicle is ever in the shop. By the time they hand me their keys, I've already spent that first phone call shaping the experience they're about to have.
The call is routine for me, but usually brand new for the customer. So, I answer the questions they haven't thought to ask yet, and I set expectations before they commit to anything.
Before a customer hands over their keys, they know how we operate: appointment-based, drop-off only, with morning arrivals preferred so we have at least half a day with the vehicle, even for oil changes. I explain our digital vehicle inspection process, that they'll receive photos, videos, and notes, and that no work moves forward without their approval.
They also know our pricing up-front. Our $85 concern evaluation is our shop minimum, and it applies toward repair labor if the work is approved. If the issue needs deeper testing, Stage 1 diagnostics is a standalone $175 service that replaces the evaluation fee. It's a lot of information, but most people appreciate knowing what they're walking into. Tone and flow are everything.
I can't give a customer every answer before we look at their vehicle, but I can make sure they understand what we know, what we don't, what happens next, and that nothing moves forward without their approval.
Customers can handle an answer they don't love. What they can't handle is feeling like the rules changed after they handed over the keys.
My husband and I opened our shop just over three years ago with very different backgrounds. Marty had spent more than 20 years as an automotive technician and shop foreman. He came in with years of ideas about the processes he'd always wished existed in the shops where he worked. I'd been around cars and repairs most of my life but had never worked in a shop. I had built and run a business before.
What I brought wasn't automotive expertise. It was intentionality.
My previous business taught me to decide what I wanted to build, create the processes around it, and market to the people who valued it. Not every customer had to be my customer. I didn't know how to run an automotive shop yet, but I knew that part.
Together, that gave us a clear idea of what we wanted to do differently.
Our first location made some decisions for us. We were miles from the city, down a dirt road with farm animals next door. We started on a concrete slab under the Arizona sun. The National Weather Service in Phoenix recorded 31 straight days at or above 110 degrees in the summer of 2023, and 70 total days at or above 110 the following year. Marty was our only technician, I ran the office, and there was no waiting room.
Appointment-only and drop-off-only weren't clever strategies. That was simply how we had to work.
When we moved into a commercial space, we could have changed all of it, but we didn't.
By then we'd learned that controlling how vehicles entered the shop let us control the customer experience. We could work through the schedule, inspect properly, build estimates, and communicate without rushing because someone was staring at us from a lobby chair.
A 2015 study presented at the International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management found that time pressure increased human error on a manual assembly line. A 2022 study in Scientific Reports found that time pressure also narrows how much people navigate uncertainty before making a decision. That matches what we saw.
The one time we broke our process gave us our own lesson.
A customer misunderstood her appointment and drove to our old shop on her lunch break. I felt bad. It was an oil change, so we let her wait, except we didn't have a waiting room. She ended up in a camping chair under an RV awning.
Suddenly, a routine oil change felt urgent. The technician found a problem with the drain plug gasket. Normally, we'd replace it, but we didn't have one in stock and there wasn't time to order one while she waited. We made the call that it would probably be okay. It wasn't. The vehicle leaked, and she had to come back.
The exception felt like a nice thing to do. It wasn't good customer service when she had to return so we could correct the mistake. Looking back, the real failure happened before she ever arrived.
She had booked online when our system was brand new, and I hadn't followed up with my normal intake conversation. Had I done that, she'd have known we were drop-off only before she planned her lunch break around it.
Once she was there, we felt rushed. We could have asked her to wait longer while we got the gasket. Under that pressure, we made a call we normally wouldn't make.
One skipped step created the wrong expectation, which created pressure inside the shop, which led to a bad decision. That's why I'm so particular about setting expectations now.
I've become a little obsessed with expectations.
We talk a lot about honesty and transparency in this industry. Setting expectations is the missing piece.
A cascading repair is the clearest example. Say a vehicle comes in with a leaking valve cover gasket. It sits at the top of the engine, so oil can run down the whole block and hide another leak. Say the valve cover gasket repair is $300. We do the repair, clean everything down, and sure enough, there's another leak.
If I tell the customer, "It's $300," what did they hear? There's a good chance they heard, "It's $300, and my oil leak will be all fixed."
Then we find the oil pan gasket is leaking, too. That's another $1,000. From the shop's side, nothing dishonest happened. From the customer's side, a $300 repair became a $1,300 repair. Understandably, they're ticked off.
The problem isn't the second repair. It's whether the customer knew a second repair was possible before approving the first. So, I tell them up-front. I explain that we're starting with the known leak, but I can't promise it's the only one. We repair it, clean everything down, and see what happens. We put that in the repair order notes.
A $1,000 repair is much easier to hear when you knew it was a possibility in the first place.
Customers push against our processes sometimes. Of course they do.
Can I wait? Can you give me a ballpark price? I already bought the part, can you install it? Can we skip the inspection?
It doesn't hurt to ask. I explain why we work the way we do, then I stick to it.
We learned the customer-supplied-parts lesson early. We once installed a customer-supplied engine from a well-known remanufacturer. It was defective, and the customer ended up spending more than if we had sourced it and handled the warranty our way.
We almost never install customer-supplied parts now.
The same goes for the other boundaries we've built. Once customers understand why we work the way we do, it's interesting how often they find a way to make it work. They find a ride. They return the part. They schedule properly.
Sometimes, they go elsewhere, and that's OK. Taking a job I know is likely to create a poor customer experience just for the sake of revenue isn't good customer service.
For the customers who stay, trust is built on visibility. We update every customer at the end of each day their vehicle is in our shop, and we message after-hours drop-offs as soon as we open. When you anticipate their need for an update, they don't have to chase you for answers.
Our intake can feel unusually thorough.
I collect the customer's concern and contact information, including email, home address, license plate, VIN, and vehicle color. I ask how they heard about us. I explain our evaluation versus our diagnostic service, the drop-off process, and timing. I note what I've already covered.
It's conversational. If something's missing, they can text it later or we'll get it off the vehicle.
When they arrive, I confirm the vehicle and the concern, ask if there's anything to add, and they hand over their keys.
Wham, bam, they're out the door.
We hold a five-star rating across 197 customer reviews on Google, CARFAX, and Facebook. We relocated 13 miles away into a new city and market in year three, and revenue has still grown every year. From January through August 2026, our average repair order was $933. We usually schedule new work within the same week and turn vehicles around in one to three days, and fewer than 1% of vehicles come back because of a mistake we made.
That doesn't happen by accident. The process lets us focus on repairing vehicles and communicating clearly instead of reacting to whoever walks through the door. The customer gets a better experience. So do we.
This isn't a blueprint for how every shop should operate. It's what happened when we built on purpose.
Don't get rid of your waiting room because we don't have one. Evaluate your process from the customer's side instead. Listen to your phone calls. Follow a new customer from the first conversation through pickup. Where are they making assumptions? What does your team know that they don't? Where could the price or the timeline change? Are you inspecting something they don't know about? Is the repair they're approving step one of what could become step two?
Those are the moments where expectations get set, whether you set them on purpose or not.
Decide what kind of shop you want to run and what experience you want customers to have. Look at the processes that get you there. Educate customers early so they understand your methods, explain your processes before they turn into a surprise, and stand behind them when a customer asks you to bend them.
When customers know what to expect, they stop asking you to work in a different way.
That's what the boundaries are for. They're about making sure we can consistently deliver the experience we said yes to.
FILED UNDER
Customer Experience
THE PEOPLE BEHIND THE STORY