
Table of contents
Editor's note: This piece was written by Vic Tarasik, founder of Shop Owner Coach, a coaching and training organization for auto repair shop owners. Tarasik spent almost 30 years as a shop owner in The Woodlands, Texas, growing a home-garage operation into a multi-bay repair facility before selling the business.
When I owned my shop, we were good at identifying work. We inspected the vehicle, showed the customer what we found, completed the repairs they approved, and moved on to the next car. What I did not appreciate early enough was how much opportunity we were leaving behind when the customer declined some work.
We documented the declined work, but documentation alone did not put that customer back on the schedule. As the shop grew from a one-man operation to something much larger, that mattered more. An empty bay has a way of getting your attention. That is why I look at exit scheduling differently today. A digital vehicle inspection should not end when the customer approves today's work. It should also help determine what comes next.
Your average repair order (ARO) and close ratio tell two different stories.
ARO tells you what your team found, documented, and estimated. The close ratio tells you how much of that work the customer approved.
If your team identifies $2,000 worth of legitimate work and the customer approves $1,200, your close ratio is 60%. Years ago, I might have focused almost entirely on the $1,200 we sold. Today, I would also want to understand the remaining $800. Why was it not approved? Did we understand the customer's priorities, or did we make assumptions?
Maybe the customer approved the most urgent work and chose to wait on the rest. The service advisor still needs to understand how the vehicle is used so the remaining work can be prioritized properly. A customer preparing for a long trip might view that work differently than someone who drives only a few miles a day.
The inspection tells us what is happening with the vehicle, but the interview tells us what matters to the person driving it. Are they leaving on a 1,500-mile trip next month? Is this the vehicle their teenager drives? Do they plan to keep it another five years? Those answers matter.
If we simply hand the customer a list of everything we found without helping them understand what needs attention first and why, we create uncertainty instead of confidence. The customer leaves wondering, "Do I really need this? How urgent is it? Should I get another opinion?" Then they stop at Bob's shop down the street. Bob explains the work, answers the questions, and gets the repair.
You found the problem and invested the time, but Bob got the opportunity. The customer left your shop without enough clarity, and Bob gave it to them.
One of the easiest mistakes for a service advisor to make is looking at a $1,500 or $2,500 estimate and thinking a customer isn’t going to spend that much. I have made that assumption myself.
It is not our job to decide what a customer can or cannot afford unless they choose to make finances part of the conversation. Respect the customer enough to assume they have the resources to make their own decision. Present the vehicle's needs accurately, and be ready with solutions if they need one.
Nobody wakes up excited about spending $1,500 on car repair, but people do want a vehicle that is safe, reliable, and capable of getting them where they need to go. Our job is to help them make an informed decision. If the customer says, "I wasn't expecting to spend that much today," now the service advisor has useful information. If your shop offers a legitimate no-interest financing option, offer it. Then let the customer decide.
That is advising.
For years, a common closing line was, "Just give us a call when you're ready." I used versions of that myself. It sounds polite, but it puts all the responsibility for the next visit back on the customer. Customers are busy, life gets in the way, and the repair discussed in September gets pushed into December.
Today, I would rather hear a service advisor say, "We don't need to do those brakes today, but based on what we saw and how much you drive, I reserved a time about 90 days from now so we can stay ahead of it." Then stop talking and let the customer answer. I also like the word reservation because it is softer than appointment. Think of it as helping the customer plan.
People do this in other parts of our lives all the time. Your dentist does not finish cleaning your teeth and tells you to call whenever you feel like coming back. The next visit is part of the process. Automotive repair services can and should work the same way.
Vehicle pickup is one area where shops have a much better opportunity today than we did years ago. Think about what we traditionally asked the service advisor to do when the customer arrived: review the work, explain the bill, take payment, answer questions, find the keys, discuss future repairs, and schedule the next visit. What usually happens is the customer makes the payment, the keys are handed over, and they say goodbye with no discussion or planning for the next service.
When the final invoice is sent ahead of time and the customer pays electronically, the pickup conversation changes. Instead of beginning with the total due, the service advisor can start with, "Everything went well. What questions do you have about the work we completed or anything you saw on the inspection?" Now the conversation is about the vehicle, not the credit card.
If the customer says, "I'm still concerned about that leak you showed me," the service advisor can explain why it was not the highest priority today, what to watch for, and when it should be checked again. Then reserve the next visit, and the customer leaves with answers instead of uncertainty.
I remember looking at a light schedule and immediately wondering what had happened to the phones. My instinct was usually to look outward. Why was the car count down? Was marketing working? Could it just be a strange week? What I eventually learned was to look backward first.
How many customers had we seen 60 or 90 days earlier who had legitimate work left to do? How many had actually been given a reason and a date to return? If I were operating a shop today, I would be looking at the calendar 90 to 120 days ahead. I would not expect to completely fill a week four months in advance, but I would want a foundation in place.
If I look 90 days ahead and already have eight vehicles reserved, that gives me something to build around. Those reservations might include maintenance, deferred repairs, mileage-based services, or work identified during an earlier inspection. Now, marketing helps fill the remaining space rather than being responsible for every car that comes through the door.
This also gives owners an early warning. If the calendar looks weak 60 days from now, you know it today, while you still have time to act.
If I were implementing this tomorrow, I would keep it simple.
Start with one service advisor and one week. Review the last 20 repair orders, compare what was found with what was sold, and identify the work that should come back later. Then ask two questions of each one: Did we understand what mattered to that customer and give them a solution? Did we set up the next reservation? Then work on the customer interview. Are we learning enough about how the vehicle is used, what concerns the customer, and how long they plan to keep it?
Next, practice the language. "We don't need to do that today, but based on what we saw, I would like to reserve a time about three months from now so we stay ahead of it."
At the end of each day, measure three things:
Do that for one week and you will know whether you have a process or simply a good intention.
Years ago, I would have looked at a light schedule and asked where the cars were. Today, I would ask how many of those cars have already been here? That is the opportunity in exit scheduling. You are not creating demand that does not exist. You are doing a better job of helping customers keep their vehicles safe and reliable while putting a plan around work you have already identified.
If 10 customers leave your shop this week with legitimate future work and you reserve four of them for another visit, you just placed four cars on a future calendar that were not there before. Do that every week, and 90 days from now you are looking at a schedule you built instead of one you are waiting on.
FILED UNDER
Shop Operations
THE PEOPLE BEHIND THE STORY