3 Ways to Maximize Auto Repair Shop Profitability

|

May 30, 2024

|

Read time: 3 min

From what we see, there’s a lot that shop owners get right. They understand how to lead their teams, grow their shops, and bring trust and transparency to their customers. But as a former trainer and franchise performance specialist, I do notice a lot of little inefficiencies that add up. 

Tekmetric touches every part of running your shop -- from managing customer information and measuring business metrics to facilitating digital vehicle inspections, repair order workflows, and even payment processing.

Because we have so much information available, we've collected and analyzed all that data at our fingertips to bring shop owners and general managers unique industry insights on how your shop can make the most money out of the work you already do.

1. Streamline Your Parts/Core Management 

One common thing I see at repair shops is an overflowing parts return shelf. Often those parts have a thick layer of dust from sitting there for months or even years.

When I see those full shelves, I see dollars (think of a cartoon character with dollar signs for eyes—that's me when I see these overflowing return shelves). Don’t let those dollars sit on your shelves; put them back in your pocket!

Here’s how. 

Set expectations with your team. 

When I worked in the shop, we had a 24-hour rule for returns. Unless there’s a specific reason, no part should stay on the shelf for more than 24 hours. We were so tenacious about parts returns that the delivery team members started catching on and checking the shelves without us even asking. 

Have a linear process for ensuring the returns are complete. 

A critical component of Tekmetric is the built-in core/parts return function. From marking a part “needing to be returned” to “refund complete” and confirming the credit on your parts invoice, having a tool that helps manage this process will help protect your margins.

Set a reminder. 

Put a reminder on your phone or computer for the last business day of the month to ensure that your parts shelf is clear. Tekmetric makes it easy to know which parts need to be picked up; just compare the Parts Purchased Report to the Parts Usage Report. If there are any parts, call those vendors and get them picked up! 

2. Track Your Marketing Sources

What does your marketing strategy currently look like? Maybe you’re paying for signs on the local high school’s baseball field, or ads in grocery store brochures. Or maybe you’re paying for billboards on busy roads, or sending out bulk mailers. 

No matter which marketing tactics you’re using, it’s vital that you track the return on investment for each campaign you roll out to maximize auto repair shop profitability. For instance, if you decide to spend $2,500 on a mass mailing campaign that features an oil change coupon, you should keep track of how many customers walk into your shop with that coupon.

After the coupon’s expiration date, you’ll know exactly how much revenue that mass mailing campaign generated for your shop. If the revenue wasn’t high enough, that’s a sign that you should try a different marketing tactic.

Tekmetric simplifies the process of tracking the ROI you’re getting from different marketing sources. Within Tekmetric, service advisors can select a custom marketing source for each and every customer. At the end of the month, or whenever you choose to end your campaign, you can look at the RO Marketing Source Report to see exactly where each customer came from.

After you figure out the best marketing tactics to get customers flowing through your garage, you can really rev up your auto repair shop profitability by having your team…

3. Leverage Digital Vehicle Inspections (Because Seeing Is Believing)

“Your coolant reservoir is trash!” the technician exclaimed. 

The customer in the lobby had wanted more details on why the shop was telling him he needed to pay $1,100 for the repair, so a young service advisor had brought in the technician to explain. 

That young service advisor was me. 

Oftentimes, telling someone that something is wrong with their car just isn’t enough to close the deal. Everyone is tightening their belts these days, and seeing an estimate for a couple thousand dollars can be really tough for many people to swallow.

However, when customers can actually see what they’re about to spend their money on, there is a significantly higher chance of them approving the repair.

The Tekmetric Difference

We see it time and time again: when shops start using Tekmetric’s built-in digital vehicle inspections (DVIs) to show customers the issues with their vehicles using photos and videos instead of trying to just explain the repairs in words, it builds trust, increases approvals, and boosts your shop’s Average Repair Order (ARO). 

You can try to explain a repair all day, but the truth is, seeing is believing.

👉 Ready to grow your automotive business? [Book a personalized Tekmetric Demo Here]

FAQ

similar articles

Scaling your auto repair business requires moving beyond simple spreadsheets and paper repair orders. You need a robust shop management software that has enterprise-level features, centralized real-time reporting, and helps you provide a consistent customer experience across locations.

This guide breaks down the top enterprise software solutions for auto repair shops with 2+ locations.

Top 5 Enterprise Solutions for Shops With Multiple Locations

Finding the right software partner for your expanding shop is critical to your success. Below you will find our top overall picks for multi-shop operators (MSOs).

1. Tekmetric

Multi-shop owners love Tekmetric because they can run their entire business, across all locations, from one platform. Featuring an all-in-one shop management solution with centralized real-time reporting, marketing, payments, and 70+ integrations, Tekmetric makes it easier for you to manage multiple locations.
Why we picked Tekmetric:

  • Unified inventory & part management: See your entire inventory availability, order parts, and transfer parts across locations as needed.
  • All-in-one solution: Instead of switching between platforms, Tekmetric offers shop management, POS, and CRM in one place.
  • Company history: Built by a former shop owner, Tekmetric is often praised for ease of use, simple onboarding, reliable support, and listening to customer feedback.
  • Pricing: Starts at $179/mo (billed annually).

2. Shop-Ware

Shop-Ware is designed to help you maintain consistency across multiple locations with unified customer history, reporting, and employee management features.

Why we picked Shop-Ware:

  • Reporting: Find the metrics that matter the most to your business.
  • Customer experience: Standardize your customer experience across locations.
  • Employee management: Easily compare employee productivity and manage permission levels.
  • Pricing: Starts at $224/mo (billed annually).

3. Protractor

Protractor is a popular shop management system for shops with multiple locations or franchises. Protractor offers advanced reporting features and shop management features so you can run your shop confidently.

Why we picked Protractor:

  • Reporting: Performance tracking, insights, and employee productivity monitoring.
  • Accounting: Built-in accounting tools.
  • Integrations: Multiple integration partners.
  • Pricing: Starts at $359/mo (billed annually).

4. Fullbay

Fullbay specializes in heavy-duty truck and trailer repair shops. Most standard shop software struggles with the complexity of fleet maintenance, but Fullbay was built for it.

Why we picked Fullbay:

  • Centralized inventory: Track parts and inventory across all locations.
  • Integrations: Fullbay has plenty of industry interrogations to keep your shop running.
  • Cloud-based: Manage your shop from anywhere.
  • Pricing: Starting at $188/mo.

5. Garage360

If you are looking for a lighter software solution, Garage360 might be a good option for your shop. Supporting quick-lube, body/collision, and fleet, Garage360 can be used in a variety of shops.

Why we picked Garage360:

  • Versatile: Can be used in multiple shop types.
  • Permission control: Manage your employee permissions across locations.
  • Reporting: Pull the data you need to make informed decisions.
  • Pricing: Starting at $79/mo (billed annually).

Which software features should I look for when I manage multiple shops?

If you are comparing software options for your chain operations, these are the modern features to look for:

Centralized real-time reporting: Tired of trying to guess how each shop location is performing? Pick a software that can pull the data you need from any location or aggregate it across shop locations within a user-friendly dashboard.

Inventory/parts management: Tracking parts can be difficult as you expand. Find a solution that can track inventory levels and transfer parts as needed across locations.

Standardized workflows: Having standard workflows streamlines your shop operations. Select a software that can standardize your operations, prices, and procedures.

Employee permissions: Managing employee permissions is critical to ensuring the safety of your company data and holding employees accountable. Pick a software that keeps your business secure.

Customer communication: Modern customers expect a higher level of communication than they did 10 years ago. Find a shop management solution that provides online scheduling, DVIs, two-way texting, and other modern customer experience tools.

Single vs. Multi-Location Management: What are the differences?

Why can’t you just use a single-shop system? The difference lies in automation and control.

  • Standardization: In a multi-location setup, you need to ensure that technicians at every shop are following the same workflow and procedures so your customer experience is consistent.
  • Visibility: Single shop software may have reporting, but you need to be able to compare metrics between shops to make informed business decisions.
  • Security: Multi-shop software provides employee permission settings and typically comes with advanced data protection.
  • Pricing: Most single-shop software options will charge you per user or limit repair orders. Enterprise software will grow with you and charge based on the number of locations.

Final Thoughts

Choosing an enterprise-level auto repair shop software isn't just about features; it's about finding a partner that helps you maintain a consistent customer experience as you grow. Whether you prioritize inventory management, deep metrics, or standard procedures, ensure you find a solution that can grow with you.

Best Auto Repair Software for Multiple Locations (Full Guide)

January 9, 2026

Read time: 3 min

read more

Most Affordable Auto Repair Shop Software (under $200/mo)

December 31, 2025

Read time: 3 min

read more

Best Auto Repair Software for Small Shops (Complete Guide)

December 18, 2025

Read time: 3 min

read more