Enhance Your Auto Repair Shop Customer Experience with the Right Tools for the Job

When thinking about how to run an auto repair shop, we might start by thinking about a well-managed football team. The different players know what they’re responsible for, show up to accomplish their jobs, put their best effort into everything they do, and perform their best as a team. Players have each others’ backs both on the field and off the field. They can think on the fly, and move as a unit toward the end zone.

How do your players work together? When mechanic shops assemble the right team, devise the right strategy, and run the right plays, they can win, too. Service advisors can stay informed about what’s going on with every repair order at any given moment in time, switch easily between tasks even when the shop is busy, and provide excellent customer service. Technicians are able to focus on their work and spend more time turning wrenches. And customers? They’ll get their cars back fast and drive away with a good impression of your shop.

Shop owners who think more deeply about how to manage a mechanic shop are rewarded for their efforts. Well-managed shops see exponential returns. Stellar team performance leads to customer satisfaction and repeat business. The more successful your shop, the more you can invest back into your team, continuing the cycle of success for all involved.

See how your shop stacks up against thousands of auto repair shops nationwide

You track your ARO. Maybe you watch your car count week over week. You know when a month is good and when it's below par.

But here's a question most shop owners can't answer quickly: Compared to shops like yours, are your numbers strong, average, or quietly underperforming?

There's a real difference between a number that's improving and a number that's competitive. A shop can grow ARO year over year and still be well below what high-performing shops are seeing in their market. Without an external reference point, you don't know which situation you're in.

That's the problem benchmarking solves, and it's the reason the data matters more than the direction.

Internal Tracking Tells You the Trend. Benchmarking Tells You the Truth.

Internal performance tracking is essential. If you don't know your ARO, car count, parts margin, and effective labor rate, you're managing without the most basic tools. But internal tracking has a structural limitation: it can only tell you how you're doing relative to your own history.

That's useful for spotting momentum — a rising ARO, a growing car count, tighter parts margin. What it can't tell you is whether your baseline is strong or weak relative to the market.

A shop with a $580 ARO that has grown from $520 over two years has made real progress. But if top-performing shops in their region are averaging significantly higher, that progress hasn't closed the competitive gap. It's just moved in the right direction.

The fix isn't to stop internal tracking. It's to add an external benchmark so you know what the target actually looks like.

➡ See how your ARO compares →

The Problem With Benchmarking From Anecdotes

Many shop owners get their benchmarks the informal way: conversations with peers at trade shows, numbers shared in coaching groups, or revenue figures posted in forums. These have real value, but they're also limited.

Self-reported numbers skew high (people share their wins). Peer groups are small samples. Industry averages from trade associations are often lagged and lack the granularity you need to compare fairly — a six-bay shop in a suburban market shouldn't be benchmarking against national averages that include dealership-adjacent shops in metro areas.

The more useful comparison is data drawn from shops operating in similar conditions, at similar scale, tracked in a consistent and anonymized way.

What Good Benchmarking Actually Looks Like

Effective benchmarking for an auto repair shop compares you on the four metrics that most directly drive profitability:

• ARO: Are you getting full value from each car that comes through your door?
• Car count: Is your volume where it needs to be to support your revenue goals?
• Parts margin: Are you protecting margin as supplier costs fluctuate?
• Effective labor rate: Is your real revenue per labor hour aligned with your posted rate?

Each of these metrics has a different lever. If your ARO is lagging, the fix usually involves inspection completion rates or customer communication. If your car count is stagnant, the issue is typically acquisition or retention. If your parts margin is eroding, your pricing matrix needs a look. If your effective labor rate is low, it's often a discounting or packaging problem.

Benchmarking tells you which problem to solve first. That's valuable when you have limited time and you're trying to prioritize.

How the Tekmetric Shop Index Works

The Tekmetric Shop Index is a free benchmarking tool built from data collected across more than 12,000 auto repair shops. Enter your shop's metrics and get an instant comparison showing where you stand on each of the four key measures. No Tekmetric account is required. Anyone can use it.

The output isn't a vague grade — it shows you where each metric ranks and gives you a clear picture of where the gap is largest. That's the signal that tells you where to focus first.

➡ Benchmark your shop now →

What to Do After You See Your Rankings

The benchmarking data is the starting point, not the finish line. Once you know which metric is your biggest gap, you can start asking the right questions:

• If ARO is lagging: How consistently are your technicians completing and sending digital vehicle inspections (DVIs)? Are customers seeing and approving the recommended work?
• If car count is flat: Are you actively pursuing new customers? Are return visit intervals optimized? Are declined jobs being followed up?
• If parts margin is soft: When did you last review your parts pricing matrix? Is it adjusting for recent cost increases from your vendors?
• If the effective labor rate is low: Are service writers building jobs accurately? Are discounts being applied consistently or inconsistently?

Each of these questions points toward a workflow, and Tekmetric's reporting is built to surface the answers at the job, technician, and service writer level. But even before you get to that step, knowing which question to ask is most of the work.

➡ Benchmark your shop now →

The Shops Getting This Right

High-performing shops don't treat benchmarking as a one-time exercise. They check their rankings periodically, track how their numbers shift against the industry baseline, and use the comparison to coach their teams with context.

"You're at 85% DVI completion" is a data point. "You're at 85% completion, and top shops are at 95%" is a coaching conversation with direction.

"Seeing them take the shift to Tekmetric and then grow profitability in the same four walls has been phenomenal. Some of them are just exponential."  — Matt Schwab, Clutch Automotive, Tekmetric Customer

Takeaways

• Internal tracking shows you direction; benchmarking shows you position.
• The four metrics — ARO, car count, parts margin, effective labor rate — are the right comparison points.
• Good benchmarking data is consistent, anonymized, and drawn from shops with similar operating profiles.
• The TSI tool is free, built from more than 12,000 shops, and gives you an instant read on where your gaps are largest.
• Your benchmark result tells you which lever to pull first — and that's where the work starts.

Once you know your gaps, the next step is building a system to close them.

➡ Benchmark your shop now →

‍

With this latest update, we want to deep dive into one of the most beneficial features, buy now, pay later, so shop owners can see for themselves.

Tekmerchant was designed to help shop owners, like you, to build trust with customers, close out the day faster, and turbo charge shop’s payment processing by offering them a fully integrated payments solution, all managed by a trusted team. Building off your existing Tekmetric experience, Tekmerchant is another way to supercharge both your shop’s processes and your customer’s experience at the same time.

More specifically, we're really excited to tell you about our new buy now, pay later feature , making it easier for your guests to do business with your shop -- especially on those more expensive repair orders. 

With just the inclusion of Tekmerchant alone, Silver Lake Auto’s shop performance continues to grow. At the organization’s flagship store, average repair order (ARO) has increased by more than $200 a month!

And we’re excited to see how much those AROs grow with buy now, pay later.